Doctor in Switzerland or Germany: pros and cons
Working as a doctor in Switzerland or staying in Germany or Austria? Working hours, on-call duty, training, pay and pensions compared, with sources.
6 November 2026
If you work as a doctor in Germany or Austria and are considering a post at a Swiss hospital, you will want to know how the conditions differ. This article sets them side by side as they stand in law, collective agreements and training regulations: working hours, on-call duty, postgraduate training, pay, pensions and recognition. How the move works step by step is covered in the article on working as a doctor in Switzerland. Whether a difference counts for or against the move depends on your specialty, how far your training has progressed and your family.
Hospital working hours: what the law allows
In Switzerland, junior doctors in training (Assistenzärztinnen and Assistenzärzte) are covered by the Employment Act, and since 2005 expressly also at the public hospitals of cantons and municipalities (Art. 4a ArGV 1). The Act caps the week at 50 hours (Art. 9 ArG). Overtime beyond that is allowed only by way of exception and is limited to 140 hours in a calendar year (Art. 12 ArG). Public-sector staff rules may depart from this only in the employees' favour (Art. 71 ArG).
In Germany, the working day may be eight hours, or ten if eight are not exceeded on average over six calendar months or 24 weeks (§ 3 ArbZG). Where a collective agreement allows longer days, a limit of 48 hours a week on average over twelve months applies. Going beyond that requires your written consent, which you can withdraw with six months' notice (§ 7 ArbZG). The collective agreement for doctors at municipal hospitals (TV-Ärzte/VKA) sets regular working time at an average of 40 hours and, with that consent, allows up to 56 hours on average, or up to 66 in justified individual cases under a regional agreement (§§ 7 and 10 TV-Ärzte/VKA).
In Austria, hospital working time is governed by the Hospital Working Hours Act: 48 hours on average over up to 17 weeks, up to 60 hours in individual weeks, and up to 72 with extended shifts (§§ 3 and 4 KA-AZG). A works agreement can allow an average of 52 hours until 30 June 2028, provided you have given your written consent in advance (§ 4(4b) KA-AZG).
The difference therefore lies less in the figure than in how the rule is built. In Germany and Austria, 48 hours is an average that can be extended with your written consent. In Switzerland, 50 hours is a weekly maximum that the law lets you exceed only in narrowly defined cases. It makes no provision for extending it with your consent: according to SECO, its rules are mandatory and apply even if the hospital and its staff were to agree otherwise.
How long doctors actually work
In both countries, the doctors' associations survey their members. In Switzerland, junior and senior doctors covered by the Employment Act worked an average of 54.6 hours a week in 2025, converted to a full-time post (VSAO); the details of the survey are in the article on doctors' working hours. In Germany, employed doctors working full time put in around 55 hours a week on average according to the MB-Monitor 2024, with 9,649 participants, counting all duties and overtime; 24 per cent were regularly on duty for 60 hours or more (Marburger Bund).
The surveys cannot be compared one to one: the VSAO converts part-time posts to a full-time equivalent and does not survey senior consultants, while the Marburger Bund also surveys heads of department and reports the figure for full-time staff. Converted to a full-time post, however, both figures lie above 50 hours. For your decision, what counts most is the recorded working time of the department you apply to.
Hospital on-call duty: Pikett, Bereitschaftsdienst, extended shifts
The countries differ clearly in how long a duty may last. In Germany, Bereitschaftsdienst, during which you stay at a place set by the employer, forms part of working time (§ 7 ArbZG). Under the TV-Ärzte/VKA it may extend the working day to up to 24 hours if the time beyond eight hours is worked as Bereitschaftsdienst; as a rule, you have to work no more than four Bereitschaftsdienste a calendar month. Rufbereitschaft, during which you stay at a place you have notified to the employer, is limited as a rule to 13 duties a month (§ 10 TV-Ärzte/VKA). In Austria, a works agreement allows extended shifts of up to 25 hours (§ 4 KA-AZG).
In Switzerland, on-call duty is called Pikett. If you do it in the hospital, the whole time counts as working time; if you do it elsewhere, the call-outs and the journey count (Art. 15 ArGV 1). For the length of a duty, the Employment Act and its ordinances set tighter limits: in hospitals, day and evening duty may fall within a span of no more than 17 hours, including breaks and overtime (Arts. 5 and 15 ArGV 2), and a duty that falls even partly in the night, which SECO treats as night work, within a span of twelve hours under certain conditions (Art. 10(2) ArGV 2). How often Pikett is allowed and how hospitals plan their rotas within these limits is covered in the article on doctors' working hours.
Specialist training: SIWF and Landesärztekammer
In two large specialties, the minimum length is the same. The model training regulations of the German Medical Association require 60 months each for internal medicine and for anaesthesiology (MWBO); Switzerland requires five years each for general internal medicine and for anaesthesiology (Annex 1 MedBV). In Germany, the binding version is the training regulations of your regional medical association (Landesärztekammer).
What differs is what the training is tied to. In Germany, the medical association grants the authorisation to train to a doctor who personally leads the training at an approved training centre (§ 5 MWBO). In Switzerland, the SIWF recognises the training centre itself, such as a hospital, a clinic or a practice, and places it in one of up to four categories according to its size, facilities and the quality of the training (Arts. 39 and 40 WBO). In Germany, the specialist examination is held by an examination committee of the medical association and lasts at least 30 minutes (§§ 13 and 14 MWBO); in Switzerland, the specialist society organises it (Art. 11 WBO). Categories, the e-logbook and the examination are covered in the article on specialist training with the SIWF.
If you move in the middle of your training, you should know both directions. The SIWF can credit training from Germany or Austria if the authority there confirms that it counts towards the title concerned, but as a rule at least two years of specialty training must be completed in Switzerland (Art. 33 WBO). Conversely, the Landesärztekammer can recognise equivalent training in full or in part (§ 10 MWBO) and checks whether training periods abroad can be credited (German Medical Association).
Doctors' pay: collective agreement or hospital pay scale
In Germany, different collective agreements apply to hospital doctors depending on who runs the hospital; the Marburger Bund publishes its own for municipal hospitals, for university hospitals and for several private hospital groups (Marburger Bund). Under the TV-Ärzte/VKA, the pay group follows the role, from doctor through specialist and Oberarzt to leading Oberarzt; it does not apply to heads of department (Chefärzte) with individual contracts (§§ 1 and 16). In Switzerland, salaries are set out in the pay scales of individual hospitals and cantons or in collective agreements. Examples with sources for each grade are in the article on doctors' pay by grade, and what an Oberarzt post involves is in the article on the Oberarzt in Switzerland.
Your start date in Switzerland depends on your notice period. Under the TV-Ärzte/VKA, it is two weeks in the first six months and one month for up to one year's employment, in each case to the end of a month. After that, ordinary notice ends the employment at the end of a calendar quarter, with a notice period of six weeks to six months depending on length of employment (§ 35 TV-Ärzte/VKA).
Deductions and pensions: what changes for doctors
In Germany, employed doctors who are compulsory members of a medical pension scheme (Versorgungswerk) and of the medical association can be exempted from the statutory pension insurance (§ 6 SGB VI). In Switzerland, anyone working here is in principle insured in the old-age and survivors' insurance AHV (Art. 1a AHVG) and, above a minimum annual salary, compulsorily in the employer's pension fund (Art. 2 BVG). Before you move, ask your Versorgungswerk what happens to your membership.
Health insurance is also calculated differently: in Germany's statutory health insurance you pay a contribution as a percentage of contributory income (§ 241 SGB V), in Switzerland a premium per person, regardless of salary (FOPH). More on this in the articles on Swiss pay, gross and net, health insurance in Switzerland and commuting or relocating.
Recognition of specialist titles, including the way back
How MEBEKO recognises degrees and specialist titles from Germany and Austria is covered in the article on MEBEKO recognition. For the decision, though, the way back counts too. EU Directive 2005/36/EC also applies to qualifications from Switzerland and provides two routes: automatic recognition without a substantive review, and general recognition. Specialist training that is not recognised automatically is reviewed by the responsible Landesärztekammer, which compares its content and length with its own training regulations (German Medical Association). Some Swiss titles, such as intensive care medicine and hand surgery, cannot be recognised under the Agreement on the Free Movement of Persons (WBO annex). If you are working towards such a title and may want to return, clarify this with the Landesärztekammer beforehand.
What to clarify before moving to a Swiss hospital
What tips the balance shows only in a concrete post. How many hours does the contract provide for, and how many does the department actually record? How are night and weekend duties organised: as shifts, as Pikett in the hospital or as Pikett from home? Is the clinic recognised as a training centre for your specialty, in which category, and what would your Landesärztekammer later credit? Which pay grade will you be placed in, and to which date can you give notice on your current contract? You can go through these questions with us in a call; how we work is set out on the page for doctors. What counts in the end is your contract, the hospital's pay regulations or collective agreement and the decisions of the bodies responsible.
Sources
All sources were accessed on 13 October 2026.
- Employment Act (ArG), SR 822.11, Arts. 9, 12 and 71, as at 1 September 2023.
- Ordinance 1 to the Employment Act (ArGV 1), SR 822.111, Arts. 4a and 15, as at 1 September 2024.
- Ordinance 2 to the Employment Act (ArGV 2), SR 822.112, Arts. 5, 10 and 15, as at 1 February 2026.
- State Secretariat for Economic Affairs (SECO): Fact sheet on applying the Employment Act in hospitals and clinics, version of 6 March 2023.
- Federal Act on Old-Age and Survivors' Insurance (AHVG), SR 831.10, Art. 1a, as at 1 January 2026.
- Federal Act on Occupational Old-Age, Survivors' and Invalidity Pension Provision (BVG), SR 831.40, Art. 2, as at 1 January 2025.
- Medical Professions Ordinance (MedBV), SR 811.112.0, Annex 1, as at 1 January 2022.
- Swiss Institute for Postgraduate and Continuing Medical Education (SIWF): Regulations for Postgraduate Training (WBO), Arts. 11, 33, 39, 40 and annex, last revised 25 September 2025.
- Federal Office of Public Health: Health insurance: premiums and cost sharing.
- vsao: Working conditions of junior and senior doctors, member survey 2026, conducted by DemoSCOPE from 23 January to 19 March 2026, figures for 2025.
- Germany: Working Hours Act, § 3 and § 7; Social Code Book V, § 241; Social Code Book VI, § 6.
- Marburger Bund: Collective agreement for doctors at municipal hospitals (TV-Ärzte/VKA) as amended by Amending Agreement No. 10 of 13 January 2025, as at 1 July 2025, §§ 1, 7, 10, 16 and 35; overview of collective agreements.
- Marburger Bund: MB-Monitor 2024, summary of results, survey from 27 September to 27 October 2024.
- German Medical Association: (Model) Regulations on Postgraduate Training 2018, §§ 5, 10, 13 and 14 and Section B, version of 3 July 2026; Recognition of qualifications from the EU, the EEA and Switzerland.
- Austria: Hospital Working Hours Act (KA-AZG), §§ 3 and 4, version of 13 October 2026.